Friday, February 4, 2011

Philanthropic donations to new medical schools and centers across the nation

A number of medical school construction projects across the United States have received pledges of financial support that exceed the $25 million pledged to the proposed UNTMD campus.  These successful fundraising efforts frequently included extensive community outreach in which alumni, trustees, business and civic leaders, and community members offer major donations and sponsor challenge grant proposals designed to jump-start contributions from individuals and foundations.  The list below outlines some of the major contributions to new or expanded medical schools in recent years:


Campbell University (North Carolina)
Campbell University, a private, Baptist university in North Carolina, is spending $60 million to develop a new medical school that will open at its Buies Creek campus in 2013.  The school will use “savings, donations, loans, and other funds” to fund its project.[1]

Southeast Alabama Medical Center (Alabama)
The Southeast Alabama Medical Center is developing a private college of osteopathic medicine at the SAMC campus.  According to the SAMC Web site, the $40 development cost “includes a $15 million operating budget funded by SAMC and $25 million construction costs financed through bond sales.[2]

Marian University (Indiana)
Marian University, a Catholic, liberal arts university in central Indiana, received a $30 million pledge from an anonymous donor in support of its planned college of osteopathic medicine.  The college’s projected development cost is $75 million.[3]

University of California, San Francisco (California)
The University of California, San Francisco is planning to build a 183-bed children’s hospital that includes a pediatric emergency room and research facilities.  The children’s hospital will be part of a $1.5 billion hospital system, scheduled to open in 2014, that will also include a cancer center and a women’s hospital.   The university plans to raise $600 million through private donations.  As of June 2010, Marc Benioff, the founder of salesforce.com, and his wife Lynne pledged $100 million.  In addition, philanthropist Charles Feeney, founder of Duty Free Shoppers Group, pledged $125 million toward the project.[4]

Cornell University (New York)
Cornell University constructed a new medical research building in 2009.  Sanford Weill, a Class of 1955 Cornell alumnus, financial services executive and philanthropist, contributed $170 million toward the project.[5] 

Various universities (Michigan)
  • Three universities in Michigan are undertaking significant capital campaigns to fund their new medical schools.  According to an article in the Kalamazoo Gazette, “Central Michigan University officials…launched a $25 million capital campaign that will help with start-up costs, scholarships and facilities.”[6] 
  • The Oakland University William Beaumont School of Medicine in Rochester, created through a partnership between Oakland University and William Beaumont Hospital, plans to raise $175 million.  As of the fall of 2009, the project’s organizers raised $25 million.[7] 
  • The third university, Western Michigan University, received $1.8 million from a private donor for its medical school.  WMU plans to raise at least $175 million from private donors for its medical school’s endowment.[8]
    University of Central Florida (Florida)
    The new medical school at the University of Central Florida reached out to private donors to fund 40 four-year scholarships worth $160,000 each, for a total commitment of $6.4 million in private donations toward the effort.[9]  In addition, in 2005, the Tavistock Group, an investment company, made a significant contribution to the project.  The Tavistock Group donated $12.5 million and 50 acres of land worth $8 million to establish the UCF Healthcare Campus at Lake Nona.[10] 

    Florida International University (Florida)
    Herbert Wertheim, a Florida businessman and retired optometrist, contributed $20 million toward the construction of a medical school at Florida International University.[11]  Through the State of Florida’s Major Gifts Trust Fund matching gift program, the donation’s impact reaches $40 million.[12]

    Texas Tech University (Texas)
    Texas Tech University’s new medical school, the El Paso School of Medicine, will be named in honor of Paul L. Foster, who donated $50 million to the project.  Mr. Foster is the president and CEO of Western Refining, Inc.  The gift was the largest ever received by the Texas Tech University System.[13]

    University of Texas at Austin (Texas)
    The Dell Pediatric Research Institute, a collaboration between the University of Texas at Austin and the Seton Family of Hospitals, cost $100 million to develop when it opened in April 2010.  The Michael and Susan Dell Foundation contributed $38 million toward the project.  The pediatric research institute is a significant component of a $1.5 billion medical school and academic health center planned for Austin; the project is expected to be funded through a combination of philanthropy, business contributions, and taxes.[14]

    Brown University (Rhode Island)
    Major universities regularly receive large financial contributions to advance their operations.  At its October 2009 meeting, for example, Brown University’s board of trustees accepted seven gifts worth $1 million or more.[15]  In addition, as part of a four-year capital campaign that concluded in 2009, Brown University raised $1.4 billion.  The funds came from 63,675 alumni, parents, friends, businesses, and foundations, according to a news article about the project.[16]  Some of the funds could be used to support the $45 million renovation of a building that houses Brown’s Alpert Medical School.  

    Michigan State University (Michigan)
    Michigan State University is building its College of Human Medicine building in downtown Grand Rapids.  The $90 million medical building will be funded with $50 million in private contributions; as of April 2010, the college received $39 million in private donations toward the project.[17]  Major donors include MSU alumnus Peter Secchia, his wife, Joan, and Amway co-founder Richard DeVos and his wife, Helen.  The DeVos family has pledged to match up to $5 million in private donations.[18]

    In conclusion, other medical school projects enjoy greater support than UNTMD business plan. The proposed second medical school in Fort Worth claims having the strong support of the local community; they only “talk the talk, but do not do the walk.” Even though the $25 million pledges are a sizable amount and commendable, the financial support does not match by far the ambition and the cost of establishing a new medical school. Texas tax-payers and Texas College of Osteopathic Medicine are likely to be the victims to foot the bill for an ill-conceived plan and unwarranted ambition.


    [1] Avery, Sarah.  Campbell plans to open medical school in 2013.”  News & Observer.  January 22, 2011.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.newsobserver.com/2011/01/22/936378/campbell-eyes-13-for-med-school.html
    [2]College of Medicine to Build in Houston County.”  Southeast Alabama Medical Center Web site.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.samc.org/index.php/ourhospital/news/330-school-of-osteopathic-medicine.html.
    [3] “$30 Million Pledge to Start Indiana’s First College of Osteopathic Medicine.”  Marian University.  January 14, 2010.  URL: http://www.marian.edu/pages/news.aspx?newsid=449
    [4] Guth, Robert.  “UCSF to Get $100 Million for Hospital.”  The Wall Street Journal.  June 17, 2010.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704324304575307111971055670.html.
    [5] Eisen, Ben.  “Weills Give$170M to Med School.”  Cornell Daily Sun.  April 7, 2009.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://cornellsun.com/section/news/content/2009/04/07/weills-give-170m-med-school.
    [6] Davis, Paula.  Western Michigan University needs major, private donations to build med school endowment.”  Kalamazoo Gazette.  March 28, 2010.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.mlive.com/news/kalamazoo/index.ssf/2010/03/western_michigan_university_ne.html. 
    [7] Ibid. 
    [8] Ibid. 
    [9] Eliscu, Andrea.  “Husband’s memory inspires UCF donation for new medical school.”  Orlando Sentinel.  April 27, 2008.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.orlandosentinel.com/community/ucf/orl-ucfword2708apr27,0,4107080.story. 
    [10] “$20.5M gift boosts UCF’s medical school plans.”  Orlando Business Journal.  October 3, 2005.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: www.bizjournals.com/orlando/stories/2005/10/03/daily4.html
    [11] Dr. Herbert and Nicole Wertheim Family Foundation.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.wertheim.org/htm_file/news_ind.htm
    [12] “Academic and Business Plan for the Development of a Proposed MD Program.”  University of North Texas Health Science Center at Fort Worth.  August 2010.  Page 45.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.hsc.unt.edu/Sites/MDSchoolInitiative/Documents/Updated%20Business%20Plan_9_2010.pdf .
    [13] Ibid.
    [14] Brendel, Patrick, and Rob Heidrick.  “Seton, UT lay foundations for Austin medical school.”  Health Impact News.  March 12, 2010.  Downloaded February 5, 2011.  URL: http://impactnews.com/health/news/7546-seton-ut-lay-foundations-for-austin-medical-school.
    [15] Nesi, Ted.  “Brown OKs new $45M medical school HQ.”  Providence Business News.  October 19, 2009.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL:  http://www.pbn.com/Brown-OKs-new-45M-medical-school-HQ,45580.
    [16] Nesi, Ted.  “Brown raises $1.4B, plans construction.”  Providence Business News.  May 26, 2009.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: http://www.pbn.com/Brown-raises-14B-plans-construction,42494
    [17] King, Kyla.  “Amway co-founders Rich and Helen DeVos pledge $5 million matching donation to MSU medical school in Grand Rapids.”  The Grand Rapids Press.  April 27, 2010.  Downloaded February 3, 2011.  URL: www.mlive.com/news/grand-rapids/index.ssf2010/04/amway_co-founders_rich_and_hel.html. 
    [18] Ibid. 

No comments:

Post a Comment